APRIL 9, 2009 6:48PM
The "roots" of fear
I
see the lights blinking all around and above me. They seem to form a
circle, like the underside of a spaceship; shining down and pinning me
to the bed. I struggle to sit or pull myself up the cold,
metal bars of the cage in which I’m ensnared but I can’t; I’m tethered
to the mattress by wires, and tubes and rough cloth restraints. I’m
wild with fear and tear fruitlessly at the restraints that hold me
captive. I scream for my mother, my father, for anyone. But, no one
comes. I’m trapped, helpless and alone. I felt like the
butterflies my brothers catch and then kill in the jar with carbon tetra
chloride and mount on a board with stick pins. I have very few words at
my command to express my terror and there is no one to save me. No one.
It
all happened over 50 years ago, yet the emotions, sights, smells and
trauma remain seared in my memory – nearly as fresh as when it happened.
A
horror movie? Well, in some ways, it’s my own private one. The year is
1956, I’m 5 years old and in the hospital for open heart surgery. In
those days, children were routinely admitted to the hospital with little
or no family support. Parents were not permitted to stay
with their children beyond set visiting hours and then, only a couple of
days a week. For a child who was hospitalized, as I was, for several
weeks, it was torture. My mother told me many years later
that it simply ripped her heart out to hear me screaming, crying and
begging as she headed to the elevators at the end of visiting time. In
addition, it was generally accepted that children did not experience
pain the same way adults did. Indeed, pediatric sized instruments were a
rarity in the 1950s and adult-sized needles and other equipment were
routinely used on children. I have a “cut down” scar (a process whereby
an incision is made and the tube sutured into the body for nutritional
purposes) on my ankle where I was fed intravenously for several weeks.
My father, a physician, remembered it being an adult-sized, large bore
catheter. Children were tied down so the staff didn’t have to worry
about them disturbing the tubes or climbing out of the cage-like cribs.
These practices resulted in a profound loss of control, panic and,
ultimately in a condition recognized today as Pediatric Medical Traumatic Stress. In other words, child-sized PTSD.
According to the Handbook of Attachment (Cassidy/Shaver)
children underwent phases when separated from their parents during
hospitalization: protest (primarily consisting of screaming and crying),
despair and detachment. At the time, it was thought that
the arrival and departure of the parents or caregivers actually
exacerbated or reactivated the “protest” phase since children would be
vastly more upset and intractable when they were left alone again after a
visit. The answer at the time was to restrict parent visits. It
was noted that “Parents were seen as ignorant and noisy intruders who
only criticized the staff and disturbed the quiet and disciplined course
of events on the ward.” (van der Horst, Frank C. P. and vand der Veer, Rene: Changing
attitudes towards the care of children in hospital: a new assessment of
the influence of the work of Bowlby and Robertson in the UK, 1940-1970)
Mothers
were seen as “spoiling” their children in their quest to remain with
them while they were hospitalized and, unbelievably, fathers were
considered to be traumatized by the loss of their own creature comforts
when their spouses were visiting children in the hospital. Who would make his dinner, wash his clothing or make his tea?
Reforms
were slow in coming. In 1952, British psychiatric social worker, James
Roberts, released the now famous (in medical circles) film A Two Year Old Goes to Hospital which
showed the emotional damage (potentially permanent) done to children
who were hospitalized and separated from their families. The film was
met with such hostile reaction and resistance by the medical profession,
that Robertson opted to pull it from general distribution for two
years. Like any other institution, medicine is resistant to change and
sadly, it wasn’t until the mid 70’s and early 80’s that it was finally
acknowledged that children suffered great trauma when hospitalized alone
and, as a result, parents were not only allowed, but encouraged to stay
with their children. The dark ages of pediatric psychological care were
only yesterday and I remember them clearly. The scars have been with
me all my life and make me deeply ashamed, but I cannot seem to totally
eradicate them.
Tomorrow, I’m going for a root canal. I
will be restrained in a chair while a dentist does things that could
potentially hurt. Bright lights and cold steel instruments will be used
on me. I will have little to no control over what happens to me. Is it
any surprise that that little 5 year old will be present and feeling
helpless? I’ll do my best to comfort her.
The roots of fear, indeed.
Comments
A true childhood fear like this one is difficult to overcome, though our senstivity to fear seems to ease with age.
Older, fearless, blonde.
Older, fearless, blonde.
I wish mine would ease with age, darn it! I've got the age part down, now for the easing of sensitivity part.
Hey - is it snowing down there at South Shore, Cathy?
Hey - is it snowing down there at South Shore, Cathy?
My wife has a fear of
being tied down, and was recently. She was going a little batty with the
meds, and tried to pull her tubes out. She begged me to let her go, and
I couldn't. I felt like shit. I 'm very sorry to hear of the ordeal you
went through. Don't worry about the dentist, they won't tie you up.
wow, this is powerful.
the years and surgeries you describe sound a lot like what one of my
in-laws experienced. i was recently reading about how much women's
medicine evolved in the 20th century, but it never occurred to think
about the history of pediatrics. i feel very fortunate to have been born
in the 70s: ritalin, alar and all!
Oh, Marcia, this is
heartbreaking. How could people have been so cruel and ignorant? We
certainly haven't overcome all of our worst attitudes and behaviors, but
thank heavens we do a much better job with hospitalized children.
Good luck tomorrow. Don't be shy about asking for some sort of calming medication. You can help fight the good fight for adults who need to be comforted. We all deserve to have our suffering minimized.
Good luck tomorrow. Don't be shy about asking for some sort of calming medication. You can help fight the good fight for adults who need to be comforted. We all deserve to have our suffering minimized.
I shouldn't be trying to write anything this late. I meant Marsha. I have a good friend named Marcia. Forgive me, dear.
Thank you all for your
kind words. Yes, the treatment of children has undergone great changes
for the better in the past 25 years. The link in my piece is to a great
(and very readable) scholarly paper; but the way pediatrics was
practiced was reprehensible. Children were scolded and even slapped for
"acting out" their anxieties. It may be shocking to believe such
things took place, but I know they did; I lived it.
"Is it any surprise that that little 3 ½ year old will be present and feeling helpless? I’ll do my best to comfort her. "
Give her a hug from me too. :)
Give her a hug from me too. :)
Marsha, I never knew you
went through this as such a young child. Intense and its no wonder
that you would be breaking into a sweat at the thought of anything
invasive. Do you have an ipod to bring to the dentist (and some
drugs???). I've been going through almost a 2 year front tooth bone
implant process including gum surgery. The music I bring that I have
chosen have made the whole process much gentler. Good luck, I'll be
thinking of you.
I'll be thinking of you
too. If you lived here, I'd go with you! Your little girl is in very
good hands now...be sure to tell her that :) Good luck tomorrow, and let
us know how it goes...
That's appalling. I'm so
sorry. And now you're having a root canal, which is unpleasant anyway.
I'm scared of dentists because when I was a kid, I had one who believed
that kids' teeth did not feel pain, so he drilled my teeth for what
seemed like an eternity (the old slow drill) with no novacaine or
anything. It was, literally, torture. Where did these people get their
ideas from?
Yes, on top of the heart
surgery, I had one of "those" dentists as well - they belonged to the
same generation who believed children didn't feel pain - no novacaine -
just several people to hold you down. Ah, the 50's weren't all Ozzie
and Harriet!
Oh Marsha, what a
horrendous experience, I'm so sorry it happened to you. Great phrase,
the "roots of your other fears" are clear now too. I had some similar
traumas and have learned two coping skills:
1. Be the adult who takes agressive charge of any medical situation to protect the scared child inside. Doctors, dentists, all health professionals listen now, we just need to speak up and say what we want and don't want.
2. Try to find some humor and ability to laugh at the idiots from the past. And forgive our parents for knowing not what they were doing wrong.
Neither is easy, but I manage better each time.
Hope all goes well at the dentist. iPod, pre-med w/Valium or an equivelant, arrange hand signals with the dentist to stop if you need a break. I don't know it you've ever had root canal, but I don't get the jokes about it, it's really not so bad. They numb you very well, to me was mostly the discomfort of open jaw for so long.
Good luck! Restful thoughts winging your way.
1. Be the adult who takes agressive charge of any medical situation to protect the scared child inside. Doctors, dentists, all health professionals listen now, we just need to speak up and say what we want and don't want.
2. Try to find some humor and ability to laugh at the idiots from the past. And forgive our parents for knowing not what they were doing wrong.
Neither is easy, but I manage better each time.
Hope all goes well at the dentist. iPod, pre-med w/Valium or an equivelant, arrange hand signals with the dentist to stop if you need a break. I don't know it you've ever had root canal, but I don't get the jokes about it, it's really not so bad. They numb you very well, to me was mostly the discomfort of open jaw for so long.
Good luck! Restful thoughts winging your way.
Medicine has come a long
way, but still has a long way to go. The mentally ill are still treated
in some barbaric ways, not the least of which is turning then out onto
the streets with no support systems, not even medication.
I had a couple of horrific hospital experiences when I was young but fortunately, my stays were short. I nearly died from an overdose of ether and to this day, I can remember the hallucinations.
I had a couple of horrific hospital experiences when I was young but fortunately, my stays were short. I nearly died from an overdose of ether and to this day, I can remember the hallucinations.
When I was sixteen (many
years ago) I had my right kidney removed. This was when they still
thought that children didn't feel pain the same way as adults. Back
then when they removed a kidney they cut through the muscles in your
side (I still sport a scar that runs from belly button area to back) and
it was horribly painful. They didn't give me much in the way of pain
medication and what they did give me would only last a couple of hours
at best. The remainder of the time I would roll around in agony until
they gave me the next pain shot.
Stunning account of
something similar to scenes I witnessed as a small child who was
hospitalized numerous times. Nothing anywhere near as big as what was
done to you (and it was certainly *done to* you) but the atmosphere left
a nightmarish recollection anyway. There was then virtually no
recognition of emotional trauma and as you point out, children were
believed not to feel pain -- physical or emotional -- on the scale of
adults.
This is an education, right here. R
This is an education, right here. R
No comments:
Post a Comment