Tuesday, March 10, 2015

VIA Rail, Eh? Oh, Canada! OS 2008

Editor’s Pick
JULY 15, 2008 12:25PM

VIA Rail, Eh? Oh, Canada!

Rate: 7 Flag
  
Our rail journey of over 2000 miles through sparsely populated country began with its first “attraction” just outside Toronto – the VIA waver.  A man who has, for the past 20 years, stood by the tracks as the trains (both east and west) with a sign saying, “Hi, VIA!” and waving us on our way.  We have just left Union Station in downtown Toronto and will not see another city until we get to Winnipeg, halfway across the country.
 
So, as I begin this post, I am out in the middle of the Canadian ‘outback’ of Northern Ontario on VIA Rail’s premier train, The Canadian which crosses the enormous expanse of this huge country three times a week.  Beginning in Toronto, the train weaves it way through the rolling fertile farmlands before entering the heavily forested reaches of the northern Great Lakes wilderness region.  Communities are few and far between and, exist in pioneer style – eschewing the conveniences we all take for granted.  The slightly larger hamlets that dot the isolated upper reaches of the Canadian Shield, owe their existence to railroad services, mining and logging.  People gather with their toddlers and babies in strollers at the railroad crossings to watch and wave as we roll through, probably the high point of their day.  We obligingly wave back from our gleaming stainless steel cars. 
 
Who are we?  We are a bowl of mixed nuts, overall.  Canadians, English, Australians, Europeans of all stripes and a few like us, Americans; so many of us from former colonies of the crown.  Traveling by train is becoming an increasingly rare way of getting from point A to point B; why take the train when you can fly in a fraction of the time?  For one, if you’ve got the time, it’s a slice of history.  It’s also a time to slow down and reflect.  We lead such busy and chaotic lives that we rarely take the time actually sit with ourselves for the three days and two nights it takes to travel from Toronto to Jasper where we are detraining.  The train actually continues on one more night to its western terminus of Vancouver.  But, for those of us diehard train fans, it’s the best way to travel.  You can be as social or as reclusive as you like.  There is every type of eccentric onboard as well as ‘ordinary’ people of all ages from kids to the elderly.
 
In my younger days, I might have been content to travel ‘economy’, but now, I’m definitely a sleeper car kind of gal.  My traveling companion and I have a double sleeper which is quite diminutive, but cleverly designed and hails from 1955.  It was last refurbished in 1992 and needs a bit of sprucing up, but is generally very well kept, especially when you compare it with Amtrak and consider the masses of people who have traveled on it in the past 16 years.  By day, there are two armchairs, a sink, a tiny airline-style toilet and, as advertised, just a few steps down the hall, a surprisingly roomy shower room.  The beds fold down out of the wall, and when down still leave room to access the sink and toilet – what more do you need?  Two cars down is a delightful ‘activity dome’ car, where most of the passengers (the chatty ones, anyway) spend their day and evening.  Half dome car and half chairs, tables, games and free snacks, it’s a social center for our section of this long (28 car) train.  There are four such parlor cars on the train.  At the front of the train is economy travel where you get to sit in a seat for three days, and, at the very end, the Park Car.  Chair travel (euphemistically called "Comfort Class") passengers are not allowed back in our section.  During the trip, one such passenger managed to slip past security and visited our dome car.  He then proceded to try to steal two cases of beer which made his presence quite obvious.  That evening's entertainment was watching his arrest in tiny, Rivers, Manitoba.  Three times a day, we all troop to the dining car in shifts and are treated to fabulous meals.  At each meal of the day, the color scheme changes – the under tablecloth and chair covers are immaculate.  Did I mention the food is excellent and fresh cooked to order?  Eggs Benedict for breakfast, lamb chops for lunch, prime rib for dinner.  Attentive service, copious quantities of alcohol.  Does it get any better than that?
 
American passengers are fully aware that this is NOT Amtrak, which is the American equivalent of modern passenger train travel.  As the daughter of a doctor who worked for, among other companies, Southern Pacific, I took frequent long rail journeys growing up in the 50s and 60s.  I was fortunate enough to experience the last of the golden days of train travel in the legendary Pullman cars.  My parents would simply let me loose to have the run of the train.  Book in hand, I’d curl up in a seat in the sun in the dome car or play checkers with a new found friend in the parlor car.  Freedom from oppressive parental restrictions, but with the built-in security of knowing they were nearby, was heaven.  In those days, trains were very well staffed with kind men (never women in those days) who patiently put up with a girl on the move  who was always equipped with an arsenal of a million and twelve questions.  Since Amtrak took over the passenger business from the big rail lines in the US, train travel has fallen on hard times.  Dirty, dilapidated trains, lackluster service and indifferent personnel have tarnished the once glorious days of riding the rails.  VIA Rail in Canada, however, has done a better job of preserving the heritage of days gone by, but as a government sponsored entity (as is Amtrak), they too are struggling. 
 
Life on board a long-distance train quickly settles into a routine.  You eat, you sleep and you socialize.  Rinse and repeat.  You get to know the quirky train attendants, many of whom have been ‘railroaders’ for nearly 30 years as had our car attendant, Bevan.  Son of a Scottish railroader, he loves his job and it shows in the helpful, friendly service he provides.  He was always available to get whatever you might need, share his many railroad stories and to put your beds down at night and up in the morning.  As we pulled into the station in Winnipeg, midway through our journey, we saw the new crew lining the track waiting to board the train.  “Oh,” Bevan mumbled as he spied a certain crew member, “I hope he’s not your attendant.”  It turned out ‘he’ was.  Grumpy Al: who could always be found drinking coffee in his compartment when you didn’t need him and was nowhere to be found when you did need him.  Any request made of Al was met with a heavy sigh and slight rolling of the eyes.  Al didn’t put our beds down properly and I put my back out trying to rearrange the luggage underneath.  Al wasn’t particularly concerned.  Brother, did we ever miss, Bevan, who was supposed to be going home for eight days off until his next trip.  Train attendants work pretty much 24/7 for either the Toronto to Winnipeg or Winnipeg to Vancouver legs.  But the next morning, when we were eating breakfast while stopped at Edmonton, there was a knock on the window from the outside and there was Bevan!  The dining car several cars back from us had been short of waiters and Bevan volunteered to fill in all the way to Vancouver.  Such is the devotion of the VIA Rail employees.  Except, of course, Grumpy Al.
 
And then, there are the passengers.  What a varied lot we are.  We are every type of human being, including the type A personality who really, really thought this would be a great way to relax, but, after a few hours onboard the first day, has realized his mistake.  We have cell phone coverage for a few hours out of Toronto, but, as Bevan tells us, we’ll soon be entering the vast “dead zone” which is the Ontario wilderness and won’t have reception until we reach Winnipeg some 30 hours later.  This throws Mr. Type-A into a near panic.  The rest of us just turn our phones off and put down some roots for a good long ride.
 
Most passengers alternate between time in their compartments and time in the dome car.  Forced close quarters tend to make people friendlier and we soon find out that we are happy to be traveling with Canadians, Brits and Europeans as they are, in my opinion, better behaved than some of the boorish, spoiled Americans I have encountered in my travels.  There are single women and men, moms and daughters,  an elderly woman traveling with her middle aged son who has Asperger’s Syndrome and families who want their kids to have the “train experience” before it’s too late.  And then, there is the Swedish couple; the self-appointed, smug Emperor and Empress of the of the Royal Kingdom of the Dome Car.  He is huge and beefy: A blond Nordic god gone to seed, equipped with every electronic gadget money can buy.  The Empress is small and pretty, but in possession of a bad back and a sharp tongue.  They speak several languages and hold court in the appropriate language of whoever chooses to approach their throne in the choice and coveted four-person banquette of the dome car.  They are here early in the morning and stay until late at night, leaving their belongings to hold the space while they trundle off  to the dining car.  They drink prodigious amounts of alcohol and at the end of the evening, their bar bill, which is read aloud to them for all to hear, is over $350.  The dome car attendant tells us, after the passenger insurrection that finally erupts on the last day, that the couple had offered her money to “save” their banquette.  The official VIA position is that seats cannot be saved and so she refuses.  This does not discourage the royal couple; they just arrive around 5:30 AM to ensure their continued comfort at the front of the dome car. 
 
The scenery across Canada is, as advertised, simply breathtaking.  The first 24 hours takes the traveler through the vast wilderness of the Canadian Shield in Northern Ontario.  The Canadian Shield, which covers nearly half of Canada as well as much of North America, is a huge area covered with flat sheets of exposed bedrock, endless trees and thousands of lakes.  The sense of isolation one gets from this area is overwhelming.  The sun sets on the Shield and we awake, eight hours later to essentially unchanged terrain. It isn’t until mid afternoon that the landscape begins to change, flattening and widening as we approach the prairies.  Trees and lakes are replaced by fields of crops which stretch, unbroken, as far as the eye can see, punctuated by grain elevators which are joking referred to as the only indigenous form of architecture in Canada.  Late afternoon on the second day finds us in Winnipeg, a large city by Canadian standards.  It’s been cloudy and rainy all day;  an appropriately atmospheric day for musing while on the train. 

The next morning, in Edmonton, excitement is mounting for we will soon see the foothill of the Canadian Rockies.  When we do spot the Rockies, they live up to all the breathless prose that has been written to describe them.  Giant peaks soar overhead etched with lines of snow and achingly beautiful rivers and lakes are laid at our feet as we cross yet another high trestle while chugging slowly upward into the mountains.  The occasional wait on a siding as a freight train rumbles by is just an opportunity to survey this incredible scenery in detail.  Space in the dome car gets hard to find as everyone jockeys for a seat or stands in the aisle, cameras clicking furiously.  

 
The Emperor and Empress of course, do not deign to invite anyone to share their prime real estate.  Unrest begins to build as more and more people push their way into the limited space of the dome car.  Exclamations of awe at the beauty around us mix with increasingly indignant if hushed remarks about the couple in the front.  The Brits are especially disgruntled and are the ones who finally move to correct the situation.  One by one, Peter and Trevor and Richard move to the banquette and announce they are going to sit there.  The regal couple tells them they can’t; it is their space.  The hell it is, answers Peter while his wife Penny pleads for him to “leave it” and desist.  The others of us in the dome car who had previously seethed silently, are emboldened by the actions of the advance guard and a chorus of revolt against the monarchy begins to build; the hoi polloi finds it voice.  Eventually, most of the men in the dome car take turns infringing on the royal space by plunking themselves down next to the Swedes who move disdainfully back into their corners.   The invasion nearly erupts in a fist fight more than once.  The Swedes answer each challenge belligerently, intimating that they had paid more for this trip (not true), but never entirely yielding their territory.  One almost had to admire their tenacity.  Almost. 
 
Finally, our dome car attendant, a darling petite French Canadian young woman, finally came up to read the couple the riot act to no effect.  But, by that time, the symbolic victory had been won and we could detrain in Jasper, Alberta knowing that although we hadn’t really put those people in their place, we sure had pissed them off.  The train left us, headed towards Vancouver with the couple still on board to fight another day.  After all, cocktail hour was just beginning and they had wine to order. 
 
After three days on the train, we had laundry to do and, finally a wonderful sleep in a bed that didn’t move!


Comments


Sounds like fun! We've been thinking of a train trip across Canada, and I think you've convinced us to do it. Hope we don't get a train with an Emperor & Empress, though.
Beautiful. I lived for four years on the edge of Glacier National Park and the scenery and descriptions of the highline northern Rockies you provided really takes me back there.
My wife and I, and now our son, take the train whenever feasible. Amtrak may have its problems, but it is truly a great way to travel -- much more comfortable than the plane, and nowhere near the hassles of an airport. One of my most enjoyable vacations was taking the Empire Builder from Chicago to Portland, where I must have ridden quite close to JD's house. What a fantastic trip!

If the government gave the rail infrastructure just a fraction of what it gives to highways and air transport, we could have a great system of passenger railroads.

In addition to the West, I'd also like to take VIA Rail to the Maritimes.
Sounds like great fun -- a real slice of life. Glad you are enjoying your trip!
What a wonderful trip; your wonderful prose transported me beside you, if only for a moment.

I have fond memories of riding the train solo as a young teenager, 12 or 13 I think. Bill Pit, the hotel manager of the Greenbrier Resort in White Sulphur Springs, WV and a friend of my father's, offered me a summer job there helping out him and his wife out with their newborn son. The position was dream enough (have you seen that place?) and I had run of the facility and carte blanche on menu items but the thing that stands out most in my head is the train ride up there from North Carolina. I had a sleeper car, albeit a tiny one in which one had to fold up the bed in order to use the toilet, but it was my private car and I imagined myself as Lara from Dr. Zhivago.

I've been on trains since, but never as private and special as that one. I hope to travel by rail again someday soon. You have my admiration and envy. Bon chance!

-Lauren
This journey is on my train trip wish list. A few friends have done it and loved it. Sounds like a great time in spite of the Swedes.

I agree with Procopius about the Empire Builder from Chicago to Portland - one of the best rides Amtrak has to offer. I rode it a few years ago and thoroughly enjoyed the trip. Scenery of Glacier National Park was one of the highlights.
I've driven the route you took. It's amazing.

Glad to hear that Via has kept up standards.

Cowgirl OS 2008


Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 9, 2008 2:08AM

Cowgirl

Rate: 9 Flag



The author with her first horse. (And doesn't that thing's grin scare the hell out of you?)
Now I know that today is to be all about Open Call Olympics and other serious subjects, but I wanted to pin a tail (as it were) on my post from yesterday wherein  I mentioned my love affair with the equine species.   After all, Friday is also an "aw"some day, is it not?  My obsession began at a young age and, like any self-respecting budding cowgirl, I lobbied endlessly for a horse, a pony, or any damn thing I could ride - how about a big dog?

One fall, during the months leading up to the big day - Christmas! - I could hear my father working in his shop which was located in the basement directly below my room.  I heard sawing, nail pounding and the occasional cuss word but didn't think much about it, because as I've mentioned before, my father could fix or build just about anything.  He felt that all you really needed in life was baling wire and duct tape.  I'm not sure how his patients felt about those items as medical tools, but no one ever seemed to complain about the abnormally large and painful holes baling wire leaves when you remove the stitches from your cut.   Maybe that was what the duct tape was for - to stifle the screams during suture removal.  But, I digress.

My mother was the queen of rules and on Christmas morning the big rule was that all three of us children were to gather in our fashionable flannel bathrobes (another rule) behind the closed door to the living room.  When, and only when, the excitement level had reached stratospheric proportions, were we allowed into the main event.  In the 1950s, Christmas gift-giving hadn't reached the obscene levels it has now.  In my family you got a stocking (ALWAYS with a tangerine in the toe) and one or two other presents.  My brothers got trains (and let me tell you, those Lionel engines are worth a fortune now),  cars, trucks and books that year, but I got...Pal!





Unbeknownst to me, my father had spent the fall evenings, after office hours and hospital rounds, building me a horse.  Some of you who were raised on the west coast may recognize Pal. There was once a wonderful restaurant/train ride/toy shop place in Vacaville, CA called The Nut Tree. Outside of the main building, they had a whole herd of wooden rocking horses. You had to wait and wait for your turn to ride one as they were insanely popular with the kiddies. The Nut Tree was NOT an organization to miss out on a possible revenue stream, so they sold patterns for the horses like proverbial hotcakes.

And so my father had purchased the plans from the Nut Tree and commenced building.  Due to power failures during some heavy storms that year, he hadn't quite finished it by Christmas morning.  As you can see there's no scary grin or distinctive star on the forehead but he did have his huge green ears and mop tail.  My second present that year was the to-die-for cowgirl outfit, complete with boots and hat.  I was over the moon.   I fell in love instantly and rode Pal all day.  In my mind I was galloping along to the Lone Ranger's theme song.  I love the William Tell Overture to this day.  I had to be dragged off to get dressed and appear at dinner that night.  Pal became my best friend and he lived in my parents' back yard for some 30+ years.  His smile faded in the sun over the years and his mop tail was lost, but my children rode on him and loved him like I did.

As I got older, my desire for a real horse was met, like all requests in our family, with, "Great!  A horse would be great!   Get a job!"  (In the previous sentence you can substitute the word "horse" with any word of your choice: Skis? "Great! Get a job!"  A car? "Great! Get a job! " A life?  "Great! Get a job!" And so on.)  And so, I did.  I worked my butt off for the attorney across the street doing stacks of menial paperwork (but I got to commute to San Francisco all summer long which was pretty cool) all in the name of horseflesh.  At the end of the summer I had saved up the (then) enormous sum of $500 and I bought my first (and only) real horse, Raina.



She was 3/4 Arabian and 1/4 Quarter Horse, 14 hands and a real beauty.  Of course, I was in love.  Again.  I soon learned that with a real horse, comes real work.  Bucking hay bales, grooming, feeding and shoveling.  Lots and lots and lots of shoveling.  My father was beside himself at the sudden surfeit of free manure at his disposal for our huge vegetable garden.  I spent many happy hours learning why you have special clothes you wear when you creosote fences.  I rode up into the hills for hours where no one could find me and starred in a thousand imagined horseback dramas.  I rode with friends and even showed a bit.  In short, I was in heaven.





The years passed and I eventually had to sell Raina because  I had decided to move to Lake Tahoe.  It was one of the saddest things I've ever done.  My dad had a doctor friend whose wife had decided that she wanted to become a horsewoman and they agreed to buy my precious Raina and all her tack - saddle, bridle, etc.  I was comforted that at least I'd know where she was.  A year or so later, the couple got divorced and I lost track of where she went.  I wish I knew.

There is a small postscript to the story.  Years later, I was down in Marin visiting my parents.  My father was fixing something (as usual) and asked me to go downstairs to his basement shop and get some tool or other for him.  He was getting old and it was difficult for him to get up and down the stairs.  Down I went, and when I switched on the light, there, clean and shining with saddle soap and smelling of leather oil was my saddle.  My dad  had called the doctor and bought it back for me. 
I'm getting older and as the years pass it seems that I may never have another horse to go with my saddle.  But twice a year or so I get out the saddle soap and oil and clean it and hope that I might still find another Pal.


I think today might be a good day to clean it while I watch the opening ceremonies of the Olympics.

Comments

That first picture is absolutely awesome! There is one of my sister taken around 1960 that is almost identical. I love the way children play with their rocking horses. When my son was 2, he would always take off the imaginary bridle whenever he climbed off his.

Really enjoyed the post!
Great piece---enjoyed it. Thank you!
Love the post! I had my own wooden horse - Buster. Ah, the memories of galloping off into the sunset on my timber steed... Must now post my own pony acquisition story!
Some of you who were raised on the west coast may recognize Pal. There was once a wonderful restaurant/train ride/toyshop place in Vacaville, CA called The Nut Tree. Outside of the main building, they had a whole herd of wooden rocking horses. You had to wait and wait for your turn to ride one as they were insanely popular with the kiddies. The Nut Tree was NOT an organization to miss out on a possible revenue stream, so they sold patterns for the horses like proverbial hotcakes. I was lucky enough to be the owner of one!

By the way, Procopius, I'm showing my age, but that first picture was taken around...hmmmm... 1956, I think. I am older than dirt. But it beats the alternative!
I really enjoyed reading your story and I can imagine how hard it was to sell your horse when you moved to Lake Tahoe. I was really touched by the time your father put into building your wooden horse, too.

My son enjoys horseback riding but we stick to a nearby riding facility as we would quickly be overwhelmed by the amount of care that goes into owning a horse.
Just loved this story, especially how your love for the rocking horse turned into love for real horses. I think there might be a children's book there...and I think it's high time you got another horse :) Thanks for writing this -
This one gave me a lump in my throat, Marsha. I love all the old photos (note to self, get scanner), the feel of decades past, and, of course, Pal and Raina.

As an aside, what a different world we live in now that kids used to line up to ride wooden horses. It makes me want to make one for Pint though, since he gets to ride the real thing now and then, I'm not sure if he would find it as appealing.
PT - if you buy a scanner, be sure to buy one that scans slides as well as photos and documents. This was particularly important to me as my father was the absolute king of slides and I have boxes and boxes of of them. My brothers thought we should just pitch them when my mom died, but, due to my librarian background, I just collected them (along with the letters, WWII memorabilia and balls of string) and stored them in my garage.

I think there might be a book somewhere in all that stuff. Or at least fodder for a few more OS pieces!
Or, if nothing else, you can scan the particularly embarrassing slides and make calendars for your siblings. Therefore retaliating for all the mean things they did to you in your childhood. There is no statute of limitations on revenge.
Love this post, Sierra. You were such a cutie -- still are, but awwww! :)

Get Out of My Emergency Room OS 2008

AUGUST 14, 2008 8:10AM

Get out of my emergency room

Rate: 7 Flag
BabyChrisNursery
This is a true story. I have changed the names of the CEO and the hospital. Mainly to protect the innocent - my daughter and her husband. In a couple of weeks we're throwing her a baby shower for her second child; happiness abounds.
It wasn't always like that.


Mr. David Thompson, President/CEO
XXX Medical Center
Somewhere in
Nevada

Dear Mr. Thompson:

Last week, my daughter presented at your ER with a fetal demise, which, as you know, is the medical term for a baby dying in utero. She had learned of the death at a routine sonogram that had been performed that same day and was understandably distraught. I knew that the situation was not truly emergent, but she was determined to have a D&C as soon as possible as it was, as she put it, “horrible to walk around with a dead body inside you.” She was 21 weeks pregnant and had not, as yet, established herself with an OB due to financial problems. Her father and I have helped her and her husband as much as they will let us, but they are proud and determined to make it on their own. I would be the first to admit that she is not a “good” patient, but certainly NOT a “gomer”* either. She was born (at your hospital, incidentally) to a 14 year-old addicted mother. We adopted her at birth and have dealt with her many problems – FAE (fetal alcohol effect) being the primary diagnosis. She has done well (after a lifetime of difficulty), is married and was thrilled to be expecting her first child following a miscarriage in January. However, she is one of the working poor. Both she and her husband have two jobs, but they still cannot afford health insurance. On this day, she only wanted to end her agony. She was told that if she could pay more, they would refer her to a surgeon who could remedy the situation immediately. Otherwise, she’d just have to tough it out, wait her turn and go to the local abortion clinic and have the procedure done. Cash only accepted, please be prepared.
On the day she presented at your hospital, she was given a cursory examination and told that there was nothing that could be done. There was little warmth or compassion or suggestion as to what she might do to assuage the grief she was feeling. She was simply another uninsured, hysterical young adult. In fact, when her husband escorted her to the restroom while we were waiting for the doctor to return with information on the abortion clinic, they passed the nurse’s station where the physician was busily entertaining the staff with his impersonation of her. I probably don’t need to tell you he wasn’t giving her a rave review. He found her high emotions and inability to pay quite amusing. She felt shamed and mocked. She could not wait to get out of your hospital and neither could we.
I have no other motive in writing this letter than to ask that you remind physicians that medicine is not just a business, it is a calling that requires compassion. I do not wish to have my name or my daughter’s name used. I don’t even really expect a reply to this letter; I just thought you should know of our experience at your hospital. Hopefully, as a result of this letter, the next time someone like my daughter visits your ER she will receive more kindness, empathy and concern.

My father was a GP who saw medicine as being about people first. He lived by this quote which was posted prominently on his office wall: "To cure sometimes, to relieve often, to comfort always -- this is our work. This is the first and great commandment. And the second is like unto it - Thou shalt treat thy patient as thou wouldst thyself be treated." Anonymous. If only it had been true in your hospital.
My daughter had her D&C a week ago. In order to enter the clinic, we had to go through barred and locked gates and doors. Abortion clinics are grim places and this was no exception. Beforehand, we went to the bank in order to bring cash (no checks or credit cards accepted) as they would not admit her until payment was received. It felt like a sleazy, back-alley scene.  If only she could have been spared the long week of waiting, the horrors of knowing the baby she so dearly wanted was dead, and the atmosphere of the clinic she was forced to go to. She sat in a waiting room full of women who wished to end their pregnancies, which is their right, but that was not why she was there.  


She only wished that she had been able to keep her pregnancy or receive timely treatment to end the agony of the loss. And staggering loss it was - my daughter, her second dead son, my grandson - the heartbreak and anguish - indescribable.  As her mother and the baby's grandmother I desparately wish she had been given the care any human being in grief is entitled to receive. 

Perhaps that is reserved for the insured?
Thank you for listening.

*gomer= "Get Out Of My Emergency Room
Is health care an issue for me? An issue of life and death.

Comments

Heartbreaking. What a thing to go through. Did you get a response from the hospital?
Yes, an unsatisfactory, ALMOST form letter. Pretty distressing all around.
My daughter, who was the patient in the middle of this whole nightmare, never heard a word from the hospital.

So sad.
I just can't imagine what that must have been like for her...It's really good you wrote the letter, anyway. At least gave them the chance to do the right thing, even if they didn't take it.

And loved the quote in your father's office. To comfort always - should be required practice!
My heart goes out to you and your family.
This is inexcusable. I'm glad you didn't just take it silently. I'm glad you wrote the letter. I'm appalled that you didn't receive a substantive response.

The particular problem you describe - late and/or incomplete miscarriage - is one that can plunge even insured people into a nightmare. The reason for this is that fewer and fewer physicians have the skills to perform abortions. As a result, one friend of mine suffered irreversible damage to the uterine lining. The wife of a friend of mine had trouble finding a physician who would perform a D&C; the doctor who finally did it was pretty incompetent and she suffered a lot of pain.

All this is the result of "pro-life" influence in medical training. I don't know if that could have been one element in your daughter's experience. It sounds as though her lack of insurance was the main sticking point. But I wouldn't rule out deskilling as part of the reason why the hospital preferred to refer her to the abortion clinic.

I wish you lots of joy with your grandchild!
" . . . the physician was busily entertaining the staff with his impersonation of her."

When something like that happens you should insist that the hospital discipline the physician, and receive written confirmation of that. In the event that the hospital decides not to discipline the physician you should let the hospital know that you will file a complaint against the physician with the State medical board for unprofessional conduct.

Where I live the State medical board has defined the obligations of the physician to the patient in the context of the physician/patient relationship. These include

* Respect for, and careful guardianship of, any intimate details of the patient's life which may be shared with the physician.

* Respect for the privacy and dignity of the patient.

* Compassion for the patient and his or her family.

A physician ridiculing a patient is not just rude; it's unprofessional conduct, and needs to be dealt with one way or another.

For future reference, most hospitals have a "Patient Advocate." Among other things, the Patient Advocate is the first line of defense against lawsuits, and they tend to take things like what you describe very seriously.
Sierra - that treatment was deplorable - I'm so sorry your grieving daughter had to experience that.

I realize this occurred a while ago, but I think you should send a copy of the letter to the nursing director of the ER, to the Medical Staff office of the hospital and to the physician Chief of Staff. Include the physician's name (it will be in your daughter's medical record)

Ask for a follow up - this doctor should be subjected to disciplinary actions (and I don't take that recommendation lightly)

Congratulations on the new baby!
I'm familiar with that term, "Gomer," and I've always thought it was horrible that there could be such an acronym. I don't care how ornery a patient is.

...and in this case, orneriness wasn't the issue, except maybe on the part of the mocking physician.

I agree with Mishima and Ann. That "doctor" should be disciplined. For one thing, he was setting a terrible example for everyone else, some of whom might have been there to learn.
Hi Sierra: Yes, please do follow up with this and send more letters. It needs to be done!! This guy is not focused on care -- if he doesn't have time to help your daughter, but has time to make demeaning jokes, he is probably not focused into his job. Actually, I wonder if he is still with the hospital?

I am so sorry for your losses and the terrible treatment your daughter received. It is an outrage.
Thanks for all your comments. I wanted to follow up further with the hospital after writing the letter, but my daughter refused (and, after all, she was the patient). Grandparent complaints aren't taken as seriously as those from the mother. She just wanted to forget the experience - who could blame her - and put it behind her. I hope that the letter was shared with the Chief of Staff and the nursing offie. I can assure you, had my father (himself a Chief of Staff for Marin General and Ross General in Marin) been alive when this happened, all hell would have broken loose.

Being someone who comes from a medical family I know how care should be delivered and this sure wasn't it.
Sierra, I'm with the folks that say that this guy's butt should be placed in a sling -- disciplined either by his hospital or by his local Board.

I can understand as a grandparent you don't have alot of standing to do this. Perhaps send a copy of your letter to the doctor who did the offending conduct and any internal investigative arm the hospital has?
There are many wonderful physicians out there doing all they can to provide non-judgmental care to their patients.

Then there are some like this asshole your daughter had the misfortune of dealing with.

Training physicians to do abortion care has so many roadblocks, especially for second trimester abortions. This means that the procedure is pushed out of the hospital setting to stand-alone clinics that often are forced to demand cash so they can stay in business. (Abortion clinics are subjected to sky-high premiums and the small number of procedures that are reimbursed by private or state-sponsored insurance plans are at a below-cost rate.)

There is little incentive for other physicians in hospitals or clinics to provide decent care. Patients have so few options, what else are they going to do? They have to put up with abuse and inconvenience.

Feel fortunate your daughter lived in a state where she could get an abortion within a week at 21 weeks. In many parts of the country, a patient would have to go to another state and possibly wait even longer.

There are many issues that lead to these roadblocks. Training of medical students and residents is the number one hurdle. Groups like Medical Students for Choice and the Abortion Provider Expansion Project are leading the way to open up the pool of doctors who provide abortions and nonjudgmental referrals.
Please understand that this was a fetal demise; a dead baby. There are several ways the uterus can be emptied of its contents. My daughter's pregnancy was estimated to be between 19 and 21 weeks, a gray area, but, ultimately dealt with using a D&E. It was not an abortion in the common usage of the word. It is performed by doctors other than those who provide elective abortions. No one would take her, however, because she did not have insurance.

The main point I'm trying to make is that there needs to be affordable health care for all.
I want to add my condolences for your daughter’s loss, and my happiness that she has gone on to have a healthy pregnancy. You are going to be a awesome Grandma!

If this is the medical center I think it is, based on where you live, I can tell you that my mother-in-law, who was insured, had a horrible experience there as well. Before her death she was diabetic, with major cardiac issues. She was a nurse in a major teaching hospital for many years, so she knew what was what, probably better than half the doctors. While on a mini-vacation with her daughter, she became ill and was admitted to the hospital. The cardiac specialist who saw her there was an arrogant ass who complete changed ALL of her meds with out consulting her regular doctor back home, and without a complete medical record. He also bit her head off when she asked him to call her regular doctor back home before making these changes.

Once she was back home, she visited her regular heart specialist, who immediately put her back on her old meds. She felt better in days. Her regular heart specialist recognized the name of the Dr Ass as a former student of his, and you can be sure that Dr Ass got a chewing out from his old teacher so severe I’m surprised the phone did not explode.
Sierra, I get your point, I do. There should be affordable health care for all. But until there is, we need to educate (read: force) medical professionals, especially those in ERs to at least show some freakin humanity. Instead, your daughter got treated like dirt and when you compained you got a "cockroach" letter.

Listen to Ann, as a physician she doesn't suggest bashing other doctors unless she feels it's totally right and the doctor needs educating. Who better than a grandmother to start the ball rolling?

Words can't express my sympathy for your daughter's--your whole family's--loss. But Mazel Tov on the new addition! Thank god life goes on.
Yes, I'm pretty sure I know Dr. Ass, Dragonfly. I had some cardiac issues last year and while I won't name the practice (which has probably 20 or more docs in it), there was very poor - VERY poor - followthrough, but lots of egos on parade. I absolutely HATE to pull the "I'm a doctor's kid" rank, but sometimes it's the ONLY way they'll pay attention to you. Sad, but true. However, more and more even that doesn't help; the days of medical courtesy to other medical families is looonnnnngggg gone. And by courtesy, I don't mean politeness.

Regarding my daughter's situation, as a physician's daughter, I'm aware of the chain of command and I will probably revisit the incident with the people you have all mentioned. However, this happened nearly 5 years ago now (fairly ancient history with regards to this medical center which has grown like topsy in the interim), and my daughter was even unhappy with me writing the letter at the time. But, as I told her at the time, it really is not just about her, it's about all the others like her.
This makes me mad and sad and frustrated and brings up a whole host of emotions. I had a similar experience, a second trimester fetal death, but I did have insurance and was treated well. In fact, I received a lot of sympathy from the nurses who saw a young, scared, and mourning woman unsure of the future. I cannot imagine having to go through what your daughter did in the state I was experiencing.

When did lack of medical insurance become a synonym for pariah? It's shameful.
Oh, dear, sierrasong, I am very sorry to hear that you have made Dr Ass’s acquaintance. Living where you do, I know you don’t have a lot of options, which makes it so much worse. Here’s hoping your heart says strong so you can stay far away from those medical turds
Actually, the Dr. Ass I'm acquainted with is in a cardiac practice in the big valley, if you get my drift. This all happened in said valley. Anything more important than lacerations and concussions usually is sent down the hill.
Thanks, Lauren. You've been there so you know how very traumatic it is even with GOOD, compasionate care.

Also your statement on no insurance equaling a pariah. Hardworking people as pariahs. Go figure. When I retire and have to pay my own health care premiums, I may become such a pariah myself. Having spent every dime on my daughter's treatment as she was growing up (see post), there's not much left for me to retire on. I will probably not be able to retire, actually. They'll find me slumped under a collapsed stack of ungraded papers, red pen still clutched in my rigor mortis hand...
Bumped in honor of the SCOTUS health care decision. Health care