Tuesday, March 17, 2015

Hot Button Issue, OS 2008


Editor’s Pick
JULY 25, 2008 11:35AM

Hot button issue

Rate: 4 Flag
 Hot button

I know, I know - I’m too old to be attaching cutesy things to my backpack purse.  But, I have found in the past that when I travel in foreign countries it’s best to declare right off the bat that you’re a fan of someone other than GWB or his seeming doppelganger McCain.  So, in addition to the to-die-for Mountie Bear, I sported my “Obama 08” pin for all to see on my recent trek across Canada.  I wore it as a sort of declaration to anyone walking behind me not to kick me just because I’m an American.  We aren’t, after all, terribly well-liked.  As people will tell you, they don’t have a problem with Americans as individuals, it’s the government they have issues with.  Here at home in the US, it’s easy to become insulated and not see ourselves as the rest of the world does.  News coverage elsewhere around the globe (particularly in Europe) is much more in-depth; there is much less of the sound byte mind set.  Even being somewhere as close as Canada is far enough away to gain a larger perspective on our country.
 
Barack Obama’s rock star tour of the Middle East and Europe has partially coincided with my decidedly more prosaic tour of Canada.  The enthusiastic world reception he has received was mirrored by those I came in contact with on my trip.  In my travels, I met people from all over the world.  Since Canada is part of the British Commonwealth there were of course English, Scots and Irish – after all, the exchange rate is fabulous at the moment.  I also crossed paths and shared bus seats with Hungarians, French, Czechs, Africans, Swedes (regal ones, at that!), Indians, Japanese and of course, Canadians.  My Obama button never failed to be a conversation starter.  Admittedly, people who travel are generally more worldly and aware, but I still found it intriguing that most folks I talked to had been following our primary and election process closely and with much fascination. 
 
And who do you think they were rooting for?  Without exception, they were for Obama, hands down.  During the primaries, they had had their definite favorites – many Brits I talked to had been rooting for Hillary - but were quick (perhaps quicker than we were) to get solidly behind Obama when it became apparent he would be the nominee.  Political discussions became de rigueur even when I would try to steer the conversation in another direction.  “Please,” I would say, “I don’t want to offend you if you’re a Bush fan.”  This would usually elicit a snort of laughter, pronounced rolling of the eyes and unflattering comparisons of Bush with their own head of state. 
 
I found that the “citizens of the world” as Obama called them today, are far ahead of us in terms of acceptance of many big issues.  Whether or not global warming and climate change are real is not a subject to be argued about by Europeans and Canadians – they have moved past that and solutions are being sought.  I was amazed at the amount of recycling that is practiced in Canada and has been for some time.  Every hotel room has a recycling bin in addition to regular trash cans.  I haven’t seen that in the US yet.  In reading Canadian newspapers, I also learned that as far as they are concerned, torture is NOT ok, Guantanamo is NOT a good place and the war in Iraq is NOT one they should have gotten involved in.  The recent extradition of an American soldier to face AWOL/dissent of the war charges is NOT something they are proud of.  A murder, which is fairly uncommon, is a big deal – in the whole country - not just in the province the victim lived in.
 
So what did all those people I chatted with during long hours on my trans-Canada train journey have to say about Obama?  They expressed amazement and admiration that we have a presumptive nominee that is African American.  This is not a common thing anywhere in the world. They wanted to know if we had the guts to elect him.  Would racism, whether silent or overt, raise its ugly head and end what they considered America’s last best hope?  They expressed concern about Obama’s safety, pointing out that we don’t exactly have a stellar track record when it comes to leaders who inspire hope in so many but also inspire fear in a bigoted, insecure few.  I found that in the world, like here at home, there is a hunger for a fresh approach; a new way; in a word: hope.  They, like us, are tired of living life at a stress level that would kill an elephant. 
 
When Obama addressed the crowd in Germany today, his basic message was that we need a world that is united if we expect to defeat the challenges we face today – from AIDS to terrorism.  The greatest danger, he said, “…is to allow new walls to divide us from one another.”  I learned on my trip that even in a small way, individuals tearing down those walls and talking to each other furthers international understanding.  As one of my new British friends said at the conclusion of a rousing, wine-soaked political discussion, “In the end, in the democratic process, we get what we deserve.”  If we stand by and become “low information voters,” paying little attention to the process, we tacitly allow government happen to us with all its abuses.  This is what has happened in the past 7 ½ years; we got what we deserved.
 
This, then, is the question that remains to be answered in November: What do we deserve? 

Comments

Great Post -- Spot on, as you know. The rest of the world always has their eye on us as de facto leader of the free world. When I lived in Australia, the Aussies were fascinated by Bill and Hillary. I am sure they were rooting for her to win just for old time sake, if nothing else.

Another friend of mine, who spends half the year in the Boston area, and the other half in Tuscany, says that the Italian priorities within conversation are exactly reversed. They want to know your political and moral/religious views first, what you do to keep a roof over your head is a distant second interest.

Also, I fully agree with Obama about divisiveness. After getting a good taste of what a push for the ultimate division of the elite from the masses will bring to the US and its basic tenets, uniting to turn things around is the only answer.
Last night driving home from airport, I was listening to News Hour w/Lehrer on radio. They were interviewing 3 journalists from Europe regarding US election. Very interest program covering both Obama's rock star tour and opinions re McCain. Watch or read here:

http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/politics/july-dec08/europeties_07-24.html
Australians and Kiwis! How could I have left them off my list of new friends! Canada seems to be a vast gathering place for former subjects of the crown. Australians in particular, are everywhere. One of the most interesting people I met was an 85 year old, single woman who had moved to New Zealand when she was 15 or so from Scotland. She was a no-nonsense, sturdy retired librarian traveling on her own and having a ball. Since I did my graduate work in Library Science, we hit it off immediately and had scintillating discussions about cataloging and other arcane issues.

I only hope I will be in such great shape at her age.
I love this post, Marsha. Spot on in so many ways.
I can confirm your sense of what's going on in the rest of the world, having (as I recently blogged chez moi) just returned from the UK. But I can tell you that the Obama button would probably have been unnecessary in Europe--the kinds of Americans that make that journey are seen as mostly being open to the kinds of input, data, and experiences that invalidate the Dubya mindset in short order.

I extract from your post the point that if only we Americans can overcome our self-absorption and learn from the rest of the rest of the Western world (scratch that--make that, "from the rest of the world, period"), the human race has a fighting chance against the crises that loom. Thanks!
Thanks, lsujp. That's basically what this post is all about...world unity, politics and international culture. Oh, and my backpack :-)

Heathrow Hell, OS 2008


Editor’s Pick
JULY 30, 2008 1:53AM

Heathrow hell

Rate: 0 Flag

Heathrow - Euro Press Photo 
July 15, 2008 – Times of London 
Men accused of transatlantic airline bomb plot admit conspiracy in court
“The Crown alleges that the eight accused formed a terrorist cell which intended to detonate liquid bombs on board seven crowded passenger jets flying from Heathrow to cities in the United States and Canada.  The jury has heard that the death toll in the skies could have reached 2,000 with many more dying on the ground if the planes came down over any of their destination cities.
The arrest of the men, in August 2006, led to a global airline security alert and introduced permanent restrictions on the carrying of liquids on board aircraft.” 
 
The case against these terrorists is just now (two years later) concluding.  So far, there has been no verdict.  I was overseas in England when the incident occurred, scheduled to fly home the day after the arrests, and got caught up in the chaos. Part of this piece is drawn from emails I wrote to my family from London.  The day after I got home, still traumatized from the whole ordeal, I merged the emails with my recollections of that horrible time. As such, the piece is a kind of stream-of-consciousness, journal-type post. 
 
It was a day of queues, body searches, and fear; with your whole identity reduced to one clear, plastic bag.  This definitely qualifies as the longest, most stressful day of my life.
 
I still have my plastic bag…
  
London, August 10 & 11, 2006
 
We woke up Thursday morning in Oxford expecting a leisurely day of touring Blenheim Palace, the huge estate where Winston Churchill was born. Our flight home to San Francisco was scheduled for Friday and we were anticipating one more day of touring before we headed home. We were staying in a wonderful B&B called "Tilbury Lodge" just outside of Oxford. The afternoon before, we took the public bus into Oxford and did some exploring. We had gotten very adept at parking the car and ether walking or using public transportation. The roads are narrow and there's really no place to park near city centers, so we just hoofed it.

That morning, as usual, we turned on the TV to see what was happening in the Israel/Lebanon conflict which had dominated the news for the past few weeks. Imagine my shock when we instead saw British Home Secretary Reid informing the public of what had happened during the night and the ramifications for travelers. I literally felt sick to my stomach as we watched the footage of the arrests that had been made of the suspected terrorists and heard about their plot to blow up airliners flying from Heathrow (our airport) to the US (our destination) using liquid explosives. At breakfast, one of the other guests had a laptop out and was checking the internet news (often more up to date) and gave us British Air's emergency phone number. It would be late that afternoon before we could finally get through to BA after getting a busy signal all day. I can't wait to see my cell phone bill... At that point, information was coming in rapidly but was still very sketchy -- we didn't know if our flight the next day would go or not as BA (and other airlines) cancelled most of the flights. Our hosts very kindly told us that, even though they were pretty much booked, they would make sure there was a place for us in the event that we were stranded.  For someone with a phobia of flying to begin with, this was about the worst news I could possibly hear.  I was beyond nervous.

After some discussion, we decided that the best course of action would be to go ahead with our visit to Blenheim Palace and then drive to London as planned. We had reservations at an airport hotel and we knew from the TV coverage that there were masses of people trying to find accommodations due to the flight cancellations and we didn't want to lose our room. I was pretty shook up, but decided to try not to dwell on it and enjoy the palace. It was one of those typical English days - sun, showers, clouds - pouring one moment, sunny the next. Blenheim Palace is one of the most imposing estates I've ever seen -- even grander than Chatham House in Derbyshire.  Everyone – tourists and tour guides alike – were talking about the arrests.  After leaving Blenheim Palace, we took the time to explore several side roads as we made our way to the M4 and on to London; mostly to keep our minds off the nightmare that was unfolding all around England. We listened intently to the radio for news updates and when we stopped at one of the motorway rest stops, people were gathered around the TV, silently shaking their heads in consternation at the situation.
 
We made it to London in good time and found our hotel lobby jammed with stranded people. Families, businessmen, exhausted citizens of every nationality and color; it was amazing. I felt so sorry for the moms who were trying to quiet crying, fussy babies and children. Everyone was glued to Sky News which was playing on a TV in the corner. I got to chatting with a Lebanese man and we both shed a few tears about the state of our world... Everyone was in a high state of anxiety and desperate for information.  Would any flights leave the next day?  Had they caught all of the suspected terrorists? 

We checked in and went up to our room which was just ok for a Sheraton, but at the same time we felt very fortunate to have lodging. Many, many people did not and the government brought in thousands of blue foam mats for them (we saw them the next day, still being used) to sleep on in the terminals and in marquees that had been set up outside. I imagine you saw pictures of the sea of people - it was no exaggeration and was the same on Friday when I became one of those fish struggling to swim in that ocean of travelers. After dragging our suitcases to our room, we had to return the rental car and then walk back to the hotel which proved to be more challenging than we originally thought. We were saved by a lovely security guard at the BA car park (EVERY location had security guards/police posted – Britain was like an armed camp) who noticed that we looked lost...she kindly pointed the way through to the street.
 
Back at the hotel, we paid a small fortune to use the internet (5 pounds for 15 minutes!! Highway robbery!) to check BA's site which was of marginal use since they didn't have any way of knowing what flights were going and which were not. Heathrow had asked BA to cancel nearly two out of three flights due to the logistics of the security procedures in place at the moment. You simply cannot hand search that many people and get the flights out.  Ultimately, they cancelled about 2/3 of the flights including all domestic and European flights and about half of those to the US. I called home about 6 PM or so (morning in the US) and talked to the kids for the first (and last, actually) time.  When I heard their voices, I kind of lost it and had a good cry. I was sitting in the hall on some discarded chairs (they are remodeling the hotel, but unfortunately hadn't gotten to OUR room yet) and a lovely room service girl spotted me hickey sobbing all over my cell phone. She brought me tissues and gave me a hug. It turned out she TOO was Lebanese and we both said a little prayer for our fractured world and all the suffering people in Lebanon and elsewhere. She was convinced that God heard us. I hope so.
 
It was a long night with very little sleep. By the time we got up on Friday, we knew that we were to report to Heathrow only if we had a scheduled flight that had not been cancelled.  It was stressed on the TV and website that there was no guarantee that even scheduled flights would leave, but if you didn’t get out Friday, there was a good chance you’d be stranded for another week.  We also were informed that we were going to have to pack everything and check it; no carry-ons whatsoever. Now, when you've been abroad for nearly a month and collecting things along the way, your suitcase gets a little crowded. Having to consolidate everything in one's purse and tote bag into the suitcase was a daunting challenge. I wound up leaving books behind and lots of other non essentials I would rather have brought home, including my tour books. But they are replaceable and other things were not, so out they went. I was so nervous I wasn't able to eat anything, but after forcing down some coffee and orange juice, I shouldered my purse (I wanted to hold onto it as long as possible) and grabbed my suitcase; a huge knot of fear in my stomach.

 Outside

Leaving our hotel, we headed to Heathrow via taxi. I'll never forget the sight of the masses of people that were there when we pulled up. There were tents set up, police with machine guns everywhere, caution tape, cordoned off areas and orange cones by the hundreds. We joined a long queue (the Brits do queue well...) along with the other thousands at our terminal and then the marathon began; hurry up and wait. The British have had much more practice with crisis and terrorist situations (WWII, IRA, etc.) than we Americans and their attitude is admirable. One just grits one’s teeth and gets on with it. After all, as one lovely gentleman remarked to me, "If we give in, then the terrorists have won, right? So we just have to get on with it." We all commented (to reassure ourselves) that this was undoubtedly the SAFEST day to fly since there was so much security around...

Guard 

Hordes of people were just milling around trying to find out any scrap of information they could and rumors abounded.   Airport staffers circulating with gallon-sized clear plastic bags with little built-in handles were pumped for news; they had little to share.  We were told that if we had purses and such that we needed to start repacking, and the pavement outside the terminal was soon littered with clothing, souvenirs, and toiletries as we struggled to further compact our belongings into our cases.  Finally, they began calling specific flights and announced that ONLY those with confirmed tickets on that flight could approach the terminal building. (We were fortunate it didn't rain, the day before we saw shots on TV of miserable travelers waiting out in the rain for hours.) When our flight was called, we were allowed into the building and into another long queue. I hadn't packed my purse yet so, taking my clear plastic bag (which I'm going to keep as a souvenir) I put my wallet, passport, plane ticket, a few pounds, and prescription meds in it and shoved my purse into my already over-packed suitcase. No cell phones, books, magazines, pens, pencils – nothing but the bare minimum was allowed. I managed to finish off my water bottle before I had to throw it away. We finally checked in and, after trying to upgrade (ha ha ha ha -- the morning flight to SF had been cancelled and they put as many people on our flight as they could and there were NO seats left, let alone space to upgrade to!). Like a herd of cattle, we proceeded to the first checkpoint. Shoes off, hand searched, prescription names matched to passport, plastic bag x-rayed (why bother? You could see right through it.) and it was on to the next holding area. For security reasons, no one was told their gate in advance and you just had to watch the notice board for your flight gate announcement. The mood was tense but restrained.  Typical British stiff upper lip stuff with an undercurrent of extreme anxiety.  Also, typically for the very civilized Brits, there was little pushing or shoving, but I must admit that most of the complaining I heard came from Americans; everyone else dealt with the situation fairly stoically.

Gate info

The next waiting area was what they call the "air side" of the airport (as opposed to the "land side" -- it's amazing what one learns in these situations); the place where all the shops and eateries are after you pass security. The poor retailers were beside themselves -- no one was allowed to carry anything on board other than the chic clear plastic handbags, so there were no sales. Acres of duty free shopping with no customers; just bored sales people standing around twiddling their fingers. The retailers, in desperation, finally printed up a flier that they passed out to travelers with flights going somewhere other than the US which indicated that THOSE passengers were able to take things with them. Then the whiskey, alcohol, cigarettes and perfume started selling like crazy. You could see what everyone bought, however, because they had to package the items in clear plastic as well. Lots of alcoholics by the looks of it.... Meanwhile, passengers bound for US airports are doing the slow boil because we weren't even allowed a paperback book. After my third trip to discuss the matter with the BA customer service guy, (unfailingly polite despite my numerous visits) he finally said, "I've just gotten an update! You can buy a book!"  The rush was on.  People stampeded to buy a book, any book, for the 10 hour flight, as they had just announced our gate and the books flew out of the shop. Many people, however, did NOT get the message that they could take a book along. I could have sold mine for a small fortune...those travelers were not amused.

Off we scurried to the next holding pen, Gate 50. More milling around, grumbling, book coveting and finishing off of the water bottles we had bought. Another queue -- men in one, ladies in the other, hand searched again, plastic bags scrutinized, and, finally, ON THE PLANE!!! It was, by that time...hmmmm...about 1:30 or 2 ish. (I think) It had taken us five hours up to this point. Well, as no one had any hand luggage, you can imagine that loading the plane was relatively quick; after all, you just went and sat down. We were delighted to find that we had bulkhead seats which, as you will see, was a real asset for the next sixteen hours. Yes, sixteen hours. After everyone was on board, the captain informed us that he was going to park the plane in a "secure location" while the US state department checked ALL THE NAMES ON THE PASSENGER MANIFEST!! Now, you may know that a 747-400 carries, well, gee, over 400 people. You are probably also aware that the US government doesn't do anything very quickly. No exception this time. We sat, and sat, and sat, and sat, for five hours. I was really about to lose it after been cooped up and going nowhere for that amount of time, when the crew decided that they had better feed us as the mood was starting to get mutinous. So, they fed us the meal meant for an hour or so before we landed which meant that after they fed us dinner, shortly after takeoff, there would be no food for the remaining eight hours of the trip. And of course no one had snacks with them due to the restrictions... Finally, after removing four people from the plane (don't EVEN want to think about THAT), we were cleared for takeoff. If we had spent another five minutes on the ground we would have had to cancel, due to the fact that the crew can only legally work for a certain number of hours because of safety issues.

10 1/2 hours later, we arrived in SF only to be met at the gate by armed police. Nice welcome. Down to immigration, baggage claim (more police, tons of customs agents) and another hour-long wait while they x-rayed the luggage one more time (it is radioactive by now) and, for good measure, had the bomb dogs give it a sniff. The water chamber for my CPAP machine was crushed even though the bag was marked "fragile".  I always carry it on board for that reason and also because I can't sleep without it. Initially, BA had said I could bring it on board because it is medical equipment, but when they saw that it was electric (and therefore could be a detonation device, I suppose), down in the hold it went. They clearly told me that they could not guarantee its safety and basically, so sorry, we're not liable. I understand, but it is a pain. I must say it was weird seeing all these tiny bags coming up on the baggage chute. All that stuff that people normally carry on, loaded in the hold. One interesting note. The passenger sitting to my right was crying hysterically for the first hour of the flight and then threw up for the remainder of it. An armed official (immigration? DEA?) led her off at the baggage claim area. I have wondered if she was a mule (drug carrier) or what...odd.

The good news? I didn't fall apart. I had wonderful support from home when I was on the VERGE of falling apart. I am terrified of flying to begin with and when you add in a terrorist plot it becomes nearly unbearable. Once we had crossed the Atlantic, where the terrorists purportedly planned to detonate their bombs and entered Canadian airspace, I finally started to relax.  We have since found out that our flight, United Airlines flight 931 to San Francisco, was one of the targeted flights.
 
It's good to be home.
BA Guard 

     

Comments

That was intense and so well written that I got a real feel for the day.
Thanks, it was indeed intense.

Book Banning

Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 14, 2008 2:16AM

Palin's book banning quest: Book named.

Rate: 8 Flag
books2

See below for more information from NY Times piece to be published on Sunday, 9/13/08. 
Perhaps it is fitting that the ALA's annual Banned Books Week  is coming up so soon - September 27-October 4, 2008.  Held every year at the end of September, its intent is to call attention to the need to protect the freedom to read. 
BBW celebrates the freedom to choose or the freedom to express one’s opinion even if that opinion might be considered unorthodox or unpopular and stresses the importance of ensuring the availability of those unorthodox or unpopular viewpoints to all who wish to read them. After all, intellectual freedom can exist only where these two essential conditions are met.
I did my graduate work in Library Science and was our school librarian for many years.  According to numerous sources, including an article in Time, today,
"...   Palin continued to inject religious beliefs into her policy at times. "She asked the library how she could go about banning books," he says, because some voters thought they had inappropriate language in them. The librarian was aghast. That woman, Mary Ellen Baker, couldn't be reached for comment, but news reports from the time show that Palin had threatened to fire Baker for not giving "full support" to the mayor.
 I find this disturbing in the extreme.  We were taught in library school that you should be willing to be fired in order to preserve intellectual freedom.  
 
As any librarian, public or school, can tell you, people seeking to dictate what should and should not be read (based upon their own criteria only) are more common than you might expect.  I imagine that Red can corroborate this fact.  I found myself in frequent battles with not only parents but outsiders as well, who wished to impose their values and morals on everyone's children.  They were often influential and well known people in the community.  Books like Huckleberry Finn (racism) and of course Harry Potter (teaching witchcraft) were questioned  but you might be surprised at other books which are challenged.  If you are interested, you can find a  complete list of the top 100 challenged books from 1990-2000, here.

If someone in power would feel it his or her duty to "protect" people from what they might read I would find that repugnant and antithetical to everything we, as a free nation, stand for.  Such people seek to implement their own agenda and simply cut off any access to critical thinking and intellectual freedom. 

Let us not forget that bookburing has been the hallmark of repressive and fascist regimes since books were invented.  If you can't read about it you won't be able to garner any new ideas will you? 
 All the easier to control you.

Update as of 9/13/08
According to a piece to be published in Sunday's (9/14/08) New York Times, Ms. Palin did have a specific book in mind when she inquired about how to remove a book from the library:
Witnesses and contemporary news accounts say Ms. Palin asked the librarian about removing books from the shelves. The McCain-Palin presidential campaign says Ms. Palin never advocated censorship. But in 1995, Ms. Palin, then a city councilwoman, told colleagues that she had noticed the book "Daddy's Roommate" on the shelves and that it did not belong there, according to Ms. Chase and Mr. Stein. Ms. Chase read the book, which helps children understand homosexuality, and said it was inoffensive; she suggested that Ms. Palin read it.
"Sarah said she didn't need to read that stuff," Ms. Chase said. "It was disturbing that someone would be willing to remove a book from the library and she didn't even read it."
The entire NY Times piece can be read here.  Don't miss it; it's pretty explosive.

banned


Comments

Thanks for this, SS.

I'm dying to know what books are at issue here -- but you're right, it won't really matter which titles were targeted, but that any were. Really hope this story gets fleshed out quickly.
Kerry - here is a list of the top banned books for 200-2005 (most recent compilation). It may be her choices were in these:

1. Harry Potter series by J.K. Rowling

2. "The Chocolate War" by Robert Cormier

3. Alice series by Phyllis Reynolds Naylor

4. "Of Mice and Men" by John Steinbeck

5. "I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings" by Maya Angelou

6. "Fallen Angels" by Walter Dean Myers

7. "It's Perfectly Normal" by Robie Harris

8. Scary Stories series by Alvin Schwartz

9. Captain Underpants series by Dav Pilkey

10. "Forever" by Judy Blume



CAPTAIN UNDERPANTS?!?
You don't need to be Derrida to deconstruct this.

First, start with a picture of Nazis burning books, labelled "Nazi Book Burning." Then, say (paraphrasing), "But, I'm not comparing anyone to Nazis."

Then have a sentence that starts with "The fact that Ms. Palin allegedly...". Accuse someone of anything and it's is fact that is alleged. That doesn't make it valid.

Then, provide no links to any story actually alleging the behavior.

Then, close with another picture of Nazis burning books and dutifully mention the word fascism.

Best of all, make the cover of Open Salon!

Better yet, a headline (Did Palin Ban Books?) that isn't even what the article is about!

Seriously, I am perfectly willing to learn facts about Palin that I would disagree with. I am all for free speech. This is just not a good approach to foster that.
Great post.
Even if there is only a grain of truth to this...it's disturbing.

We know a girl that had religion forced upon her and she was banned by her mother from ready Harry Potter in her early teens. No big surprise she has battled drugs and is now unmarried and pregnant with her second child. She is only nineteen.

Links to a scource or two would be nice.
I agree that this is a serious issue - but I am not clear, really, that it is an issue that involves Sarah Palin. There just isn't enough information in this post. Has she been accused, specifically. of trying to ban books? Who are her accusers and are they in a position to know? Has she been asked about this, has she responded?

I find stories like this to be very dangerous - it creates an inflammatory response but the target is totally speculative. Personally I prefer to see stories like this not be brought to a boil until there is real information about the behaviors at issue.
Well it's not hard to understand why she would ban something like Captain Underpants and the Attack of the Incredibly Naughty Cafeteria Ladies from Outer Space. It's pretty subversive stuff. Dav Pilkey is obviously an Al Queda operative as evidenced by the subtext in Captain Underpants and Perilous Plot of Professor Poopypants, no doubt a ruse to prevent children from wiping properly.
Kerry,

If you're still here... BBW would make a great open call later this month. Perhaps invite readers/writers to write about one of their favorite banned books? It could be quite an event!
I'm aware of two mainstream news sources, but neither is direct, so McGarrett's comment should carry some weight. One is Time:

Stein [ed: John Stein, the previous mayor of Wasilla] says that as mayor, Palin continued to inject religious beliefs into her policy at times. "She asked the library how she could go about banning books," he says, because some voters thought they had inappropriate language in them. "The librarian was aghast." That woman, Mary Ellen Baker, couldn't be reached for comment, but news reports from the time show that Palin had threatened to fire Baker for not giving "full support" to the mayor.

The other is Politico:

Palin Asked City Librarian About Censoring Books, Insisted It Was ‘Rhetorical.’ In 1996, according to the Frontiersman, Wasilla’s library director Mary Ellen Emmons said Palin asked her outright if she could live with censorship of library books. Emmons said, “This is different than a normal book-selection procedure or a book-challenge policy. … She was asking me how I would deal with her saying a book can’t be in the library.” Palin said in response, “Many issues were discussed, both rhetorical and realistic in nature.” [Frontiersman, 12/18/96]
The reference to Sarah Palin's alleged book banning (not burning) is in a Time.com article, that can be read here:

http://www.time.com/time/politics/article/0,8599,1837918,00.html

I'll go on record as saying I would like inflammatory posts such as this one to be a bit better sourced, too. The Nazi book burning pics invokes Godwin's Law before even a single comment is written.
I, too, am with McGarrett50's argument. I've been trying to nail this down myself, with confirmation thus far.
The more I learn about this woman, the more my first impression of her has been confirmed. Although this won't mean anything to most of you, she reminds me exactly of my sister-in-law. That would not be a good thing.

I am interested to learn more about the banned books episode -- she seems to be more than a little bit of a control freak. Thanks, SS!
Context: This is a response to a post of mine, in which I cited the Time post (links, quotes above), which has gotten rather major pick up. As a bit of a library expert, I think Sierra's post carried extra weight.

I do not recall the Nazi images on the post earlier, however. Sierra, were those added in?
I have updated my post with links and quotes to the Time article I used as the basis for my post. I was responding to Kerry's Open Call with respect to this issue. I wrote it at the end of the school day in a bit of a rush -- not a good idea, I know. I was hurrying to meet Julie Delio, another OSer for dinner - pictures tomorrow!

As to the images I used, I realize they were inflammatory and got in the way of my message. They were merely examples of fairly recent banning and destruction of books in the last century. I also ran across accounts of biblioclasm from ancient China, the destruction of Mayan codes by the Spanish, in Pennsylvania and in Kasmir in 2001.

Taking away the right to read is the first step towards defining how a population will be expected to think. Intellectual freedom is dangerous to the despot. I hope we never go there and that's why we must always rally behind this most important freedom: Free people read freely.
Hear, hear, Sierrasong. This story should give every American a chill, and serve as a serious warning about her character, her agenda, and what she is likely to do with infinitely more power at her fingertips.
siera, thanks for the well written post.

While this post cannot prove or disprove the allegation that Palin sought to ban books from the Wasilla library, it does offer a very good primer on WHY BANNING BOOKS IS BAD.

This is important: because if this allegation is confirmed, there will be palenty of spin about what her intentions were and why it's overblown.

And just btw: if these allegations are proven to be false and she didn't really fire a librarian over it, etc: is anyone reassured by someone who would respond to such allegations with "it was rhetorical"?

WTF does that mean? I should feel better about someone who talks about books being banned like it's a good idea?
>> The more I learn about this woman, the more my first impression of her has been confirmed.

The problem is, when your 'learning' comes from unsubstantiated and spun fear mongering like this article, you are bound to merely confirm your 'first impressions.'

As a religious conservative, I wouldn't want tax money spent on books for our children that were inappropriate, and asking the Librarian how that is accomplished is hardly a ban.

Part of the problem is that some of the materials that come out from the far left on sexuality are really beyond the pale, and really NOT appropriate, unless you want your children sexually active at a young age (as opposed to educated).

You can believe that liberal organizations who are in the tank for Obama (just ask Hillary) will gobble up and regurgitate such crap for the unthinking masses, esp. the liberals who trust them as 'objective.' If the NYT, Time, or NBC run headlines against Palin, I would take them with a grain of salt and find better sources, or look up their supposed sources. Odds are, it's all finely filtered and spun for you.
And btw, rumors of being 'threatened with firing' are just that - rumors. Baker was NOT fired, and retired her job three years later. Just because the person in power disagrees with you doesn't make them oppressive. What tripe this whole thing seems to be!
As an American, I don't want religious conservatives deciding for me which books are appropriate to have in publicly funded libraries.
Donna, maybe dg sinclair is onto something. Perhaps if then-Mayor Palin had succeeded, her oldest daughter would have had a rudimentary grasp of human reproduction and not been engaged in shenanigans with a young man.
Tom Sawyer is inappropriate? Of Mice and Men? I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings? Captain UNDERPANTS? Please take a look at the link I provided above and see what some of the challenged books are. I think you may be surprised; perhaps not. Perhaps you've challenged some of these very books. After all, as a religious conservative, I'm sure you know better which books are appropriate.

And, respectfully, would you mind sourcing your contention that Ms. Baker was not fired and "retired her job (sic)" three years
later?

Also, could you tell me who you propose should be in charge of deeming what is and is not appropriate? And, are you sure that it was only children's books that are challenged? Again, I think you would be surprised.

Perhaps you'd like ME to tell YOU what you should read or not read. Seems only fair since are so generously offering to do that favor for me.
dg sinclair - in the hopes of learning something here - when you say
"Part of the problem is that some of the materials that come out from the far left on sexuality are really beyond the pale"
could you be more specific - which materials? Also, how are they tied to the far left?
Regarding the media - what sources do you trust?
Thanks -
Hmmm...hey, Donna -- I wonder what happened to dg sinclair?

This appears to be hit and run commenting at its finest!
I completely agree.

As well, it made me really angry when country radio tried to ruin the Dixie Chicks by keeping their songs off the air.

No one is served when unpopular points of view are silenced.
It seems that the reality of the situation becomes obscured in the 'fog of war' -- the fact that anyone wants to tell me what is and is not available for me to read or study -- bothers me. I seldom consider myself a 'scholar' -- though if you were to look at my life in a broad over-view I would guess that I am. Not by choice.

Many of my friends are librarians -- I even loved one once. Some of my friends are married to them. Their job is far more difficult than one can imagine -- they have some secret ritual they go through so even the most left and most right wing see that their job is to present a balanced view of our world --

This is not about right or left, right or wrong -- it is about access to information. There are those who, with disgust, purchase a Holy Q'uran to sit on a shelf, and then spend countless dollars replacing it as it is defiled by infidels -- and the same is true of other Holy Books --

Some books are for children, others for adults, and some precocious children might be required to have parental OK's for the books they check out -- at thirteen I was reading books on nuclear fusion and fission to not be terrified of nuclear weapons -- I told myself that ignorance was the root of my fear.

Seems I was wrong. So I could check out books about something as obscene as nuclear war and tactics, and yet, THE sexist sentence I read was the last sentence in a mystery novel while sitting in a hotel loby in France or Italy about ten -- "Their lips met, their bodies met."

almost fifty years later I remember that sentence - pornographic -- hardly. life changing, for me, yeah. And so that book should be banned?

We all have different ideas, that is what makes us so strong -- OUR powerful image of book burnings are the Nazi's -- but Pol Pot put Hitler to shame -- as did Mao in the Cultural Revolution.

Hitler was but a child when it came to oppression. However many learned well from him -- and as he may have taken one step -- it was not the first -- Formation-Reformation was not a fun time to live either.

So -- for a bit my mother was a school nurse -- and our house was FULL of pamphlets about reaching puberty, STD's, pictures reasonably graphic -- and, looking back, I would wonder if those were Godless Pornographic tracts that lead our generation down the roads and byways of perdition. With pamphlets like that, no wonder we lost the Vietnam war, no wonder we had riots in Chicago -- no wonder HIV appeared -- Gods Holy and Vengeful Revenge for a world of perverts!

You guys, it's NOT ABOUT RIGHT AND LEFT -- it's about access to information -- and what information is accessible.

We ALL want most people to agree with us, to validate us, but THANK GOD THEY DON'T!

When I was doing a couple of my stints at school, there was a drain dead center between to towers of the university library. When I'd get stuck at 3AM and the library was closed, I'd get on my bicycle and go down and stand on top of that drain -- dead center between the accumulated Knowledge of Humankind -- and just suck in the Power and Energy -- I wish it was a hippie thing -- but it was so real it was nearly palpable.

When, after a day of dead end searching, I could go there and try to find an answer -- all pre web, and mostly pre net -- computers were the IBM 360 -- all terminals were 'dumb' -- and we didn't have any anyway. And then I'd go home and go the 'the GREAT LIBRARY IN THE SKY' where I'd be shown knowledge that I woke up knowing but looking in my notes had no source for. Frustration.

And sometimes, even now, I cry when I think about the destruction of the Great Libraries at Carthage and Alexandria. The Islamics didn't care WHAT the book or map was, if it came into port, it was copied by scribes and returned. Offensive to some Imam who thinks he spoke for Prophet Mohammad? Ok, copy it and put it on the shelf.

Dissatisfaction is a sure sigh of growth.

The point is, demons are everywhere -- and the best way to fight them is by holding up a book, it works better than garlic, trust me.

Want to take over the world? The first thing you do is kill everyone on this list, our families and everyone we know. Right or Left -- we have something that destroys governments: Knowledge and the ability to use it.

SS was right on in her original post -- she just used a very modern and vivid metaphor for a current reality the asking of how to ban a book while in office may or may not have been on a personal agenda -- I've often asked unpopular questions for others. Somehow I divine this is not the case in this instance.

Google Banned Book week and you'll get about a half a million hits.

It sure boils blood on both sides.

Me? I don't mind seeing a Q'uran next to a Bible or a Catholic Bible next to a Protestant one. In fact, It brings a quiet joy to my heart.

And, sometimes a melancholy sadness when I know that I can tell the difference between Catholic torture and Protestant torture.

Feeling uncomfortable is a sure sign of thought. -- pg --
Updated post with the name of a book Ms. Palin allegedly objected to when Mayor of Wasilla, per the NY Times piece to be published tomorrow.
"It was disturbing that someone would be willing to remove a book from the library and she didn't even read it."

Disturbing, but not surprising. Readers generally would be unwilling to censor books; whereas, non-readers might very easily. This reminds me of the character Tom in The Great Gatsby. Somewhere it talks about where Tom has only read one book in his life, some sort of history or political book, from which his entire world view emanates. Maybe Palin is like Tom.

I know I gave you a hard time over your first draft of this; thanks for continuing to update it. It's an important story.
I don't think banning any kind of books are suposed to be banned! Doing this is a limitation of free speech. Although the opinions presented in some books may be considered offensive to some, we all should have the right to choose what we read. I sell textbooks in a small shop near my house and I never tried to hide or refuse any book people brought no matter the content. I believe I respect the right to culture!

Saturday, March 14, 2015

Getting Out of My Comfort Zone

Getting Out of My Comfort Zone

by MT
(Lake Tahoe, Nevada)
The View From the Top of the World
The View From the Top of the World
In only 9 days, I will retire from my 34 year career as a teacher. I am alternating between exhilaration and sheer panic! Moving from a structured life to a more free-flowing one is difficult for someone with an anxiety disorder like me. So, yesterday, I decided to push my comfort zone a bit...

Sunday, June 2. As I get older, I grow more fearful of new experiences, especially those which involve physical exertion. I might have a heart attack somewhere out where they can’t rescue me, I might meet a bear (I live at Lake Tahoe - we have lots of bears here, so this is not a random, weird fear), I might get lost and not be found because my cell phone battery died, I might…well, you get the idea. For me, it seems to be all about safety.

So, on Sunday I took a small step and did a new two mile hike up to a fire lookout station. I don’t have much problem with hikes I’ve taken before – it’s the new and different experiences that pose a challenge for me. After all, hospital facilities are rarely found on a fire road in the woods!

The trail was rated as “easy/moderate” but was steeper than I was led to believe and uphill all the way. I had to stop often to catch my breath. As I listened to my heart screaming for mercy and struggling to breathe, I felt the old fear of dropping dead right then and there in the middle of the fire road where no one would ever find me. However, I persevered and trudged (albeit slowly) on.

I stopped frequently and enjoyed the view and chatted with the many paragliders who were humping their equipment up to the same destination. “How silly I am,” I thought, “There are plenty of people around to pick up my dead body and they could easily carry it considering how much they have on their backs!” I was merely hiking to the top of the mountain – they were planning to jump OFF the damn thing!

I am proud to say that I didn’t give up and turn back and the view from 7100 feet was worth it.

This particular fire lookout site (they tore the 1927 building down in the early 2000s) is high above the north shore of Lake Tahoe and at 1000 feet above lake level you can see the towns strung together like beads on a tree-lined chain with wide swaths of gorgeous beaches leading to the lake.  

It was spectacular and gave me a new perspective on this beautiful place I call home.

I’ve been meaning to do this particular hike for about 35 years and I have finally followed through. Better late than never!

The trip back down the mountain was glorious. I was so excited that I accomplished this small goal, there were people to talk to on the trail and some of their excitement about what THEY were about to do (paraglide off the top) rubbed off on me. And, of course, it was all downhill from there!

Lesson: I am 62 and I can still hike uphill to a destination 7100 ft. above sea level. I am blessed with health, a beautiful environment and I didn’t give up. That’s enough for one day!

Friday, March 13, 2015

Late to the Party for Susan, OS 2008

SEPTEMBER 27, 2008 3:12PM

Late to the party for Susan

Rate: 11 Flag
Apple Hill

 Sunflowers at Apple Hill, fall, 2007

Beauty is all around us, especially at this time of year.  Here are a few of my favorite shots taken in the last year.  I'm by no means a professional, but I try to see the beauty - even in the small things. 

Nootka rose Alaska

Nootka rose seen in Alaska

 Mt. Shasta

Mt. Shasta, fall 2007

Bridge to nowhere

A lovely bridge to nowhere...near my house...over the creek

Peyto Lake Canada

Peyto Lake, Canadian Rockies, Alberta, Canada
  

Comments

To put it mildly, you go to neat places.
Marsha, these are beautiful. I especially love the sunflowers--the brilliance and the boldness to me of the sunflowers just screams LIVE LIFE WELL.
wow! great colors Marsha! wonderful shots.

I've added your post to the bottom of my Susan post. I hope I have them all now.
Thank you all. I love color. (And saturation, eh, Barry?? :-)
These are lovely, Marsha! I especially love the Nootka rose - they've come to mean Northwest summer for me. I wish you could embed its perfume :)

And the sunflowers! Have never seen that variety, petals as long as a lop-eared rabbit. Love 'em!
Honey, you are not at all late to the party. You are just on time. For anyone having the pleasure to watch these photo collections unfold over time, it really is a job, like a meal where they keep bringing out course after course of gourmet delicacies. You need a little time to savor them, some moments between to sit back and feel contented.

You may not be a professional, but you definitely have an artist's eye. Add me to the list of people who can't get enough of color, that deep saturation, the take-your-breath-away color combinations. I love the way the sunflowers' petals have grown all soft and drapey, and seem to be waving in a gentle breeze.

Thank you many times over for your sweet contribution to the "Hell with cancer, I have better things to do" celebration!

Now I have to veer off topic for a second and tell you that the "MB" in my screen name MB Suzie stands for Madame Beloved. This is what my surrogate children call me. Some of their real parents even call me this now. It is short for Madame Beloved Dictator, the name I took when my son was in 7th grade and I often had a house full of unruly boys. So I fully appreciate your title!
Beautiful, Marsha! Mt. Shasta is one of my favorite spots. My wife and I go almost every year to a week-long yoga retreat at a hot springs near Weed. Just magic. Looks like it's never to late to join this party.
I love the bridge. Great photos.
Now I have to veer off topic for a second and tell you that the "MB" in my screen name MB Suzie stands for Madame Beloved.

Going even further off-topic (and I intend no connection to your nickname, Susan!), this reminds me of a passage I recently came across in Robertson Davies's Leaven of Malice, which I'm rereading. One of the characters is recalling a cartoon from Punch, in which a young mother is talking to her toddler: "And what does Mommy call her darling?" "Blubadub." "That's right! Beloved Dove."

Approximately. But now I love the name Blubadub. Too bad there are so few opportunities to use it.
Yes, colors, colors!!

I was late to the party too - sometimes sleep IS necessary........
Sunflowers like that always remind me of post-coital exhaustion.

Beautiful.
Awesome! I LOOOOOVE the little bridge!! :)
Now if I may correct the typos in my comment (brain is shorting out apparently) what I thought I was typing was that it is a JOY to watch these photos unfold over time.

And, Ms. Priddy! Why, I do declare! I will nevah look at sunflowers quite the same again. (Hee.)
gorgeous. thank you. I love the bridge. and I love the Mt. Shasta one.
oh, I pretty much love them all - what an incredible collection of color and texture.
Oh, pshaw. You're all too kind. I am just the "see-er" of pretty things and hope they bring cheer to the "hell with cancer" party. I've got a bunch of fall shots I'm readying (in my mind, anyway) for a post in the next week. Maybe we could all "fall" into a better mood if we put up our best shots of the leaves and colors of the season?
Oh, and ePriddy...love, love, love your analogy...you wicked girl, you!!!
I will not believe it is just me.

They just look so wiped out and happy.

A cleaner analogy, for children and the shy:

like a dog lolling his tongue in the breeze after a hard game of catch.

(still dirty, isn't it?)
Ain't nothing dirty about it, ePriddy. Birds do it. Bees do it. Dogs with lolling tongues do it ;)
I would love to be looking for lizards under that foot bridge right about now.
Beautiful! I especially like the last 3, they feel like Oregon. Isn't it cool when you see the mountain poking up through and above the clouds? It's also very cool to be on the mountain, looking DOWN at the clouds! Thanks for sharing. :)
Great shots and thoughts!